guides/lighter vs hyperliquid

Lighter vs Hyperliquid for taxes

updated november 2026 · ~5 min · basisproof research · not tax advice

Same obligations, different plumbing

Start with what doesn't differ. Neither venue is custodial, neither has KYC, and neither issues a 1099-DA — or any form at all. Neither is a CFTC-registered board of trade, so Section 1256's 60/40 treatment is off the table on both: realized perp PnL is short-term capital gain or loss on Form 8949, on either venue, for a US filer.

Funding settles hourly on both venues and carries the same unsettled character question — ordinary income versus an adjustment inside position PnL. If you moved from one venue to the other, your obligations moved with you unchanged. What did not move is the data.

Where your history actually lives

Hyperliquid runs its own L1. The fills endpoint serves a rolling window of roughly 30 hours; anything older lives on indexers like HypurrScan, which are reconstruction tools, not the venue. Collateral moves on Hyperliquid's own chain — invisible to every EVM wallet import.

Lighter is a zk-rollup settling to Ethereum. Its trade endpoint serves a wider rolling window — roughly three weeks — but with a nastier trap: the window can open mid-position, where the first row carries a non-zero position_size_before proving the account traded before the record starts. The full history is published by the venue itself as public parquet archives — every fill since day one. And the collateral ledger isn't in the trading API at all: deposits and withdrawals are zkLighter contract events on Ethereum L1, including deposits relayed through third-party contracts that a naive transfer scan misses.

The account model and the fee model

On Hyperliquid, an address is an account; sub-accounts are additional addresses you control. On Lighter, the account is a numeric index — and one L1 address can control several account indexes, which is the reverse of how most tools model a wallet. Matching 'your' activity means enumerating indexes, not addresses.

Fees differ in kind, not just rate. Hyperliquid charges signed fees that include a maker-rebate stream — a positive fee is money back. Lighter's most common fee schedule is zero; where fees apply they are a pure cost, and there is no rebate line to confuse. The numbers look similar in an export and mean different things.

Which is actually easier to file

Honest answer: neither is easy, but they fail differently. Hyperliquid has partial tax-software integrations — partial being the operative word: a sync can look complete while silently truncating at the API window, which is arguably worse than no sync because it looks finished. Lighter has no integrations at all today — nothing misleads you, and nothing helps you either.

The counterweight: Lighter's public parquet archive is the better canonical source — complete fills published by the venue itself, verifiable without trusting an indexer's reconstruction. If you trade both venues, they are two separate books: transfers between them go through Ethereum L1 or a CEX, and those legs need matching before anything becomes a disposal. The obligation is one filing; the evidence is two pipelines.

Common questions

?Does either venue report to the IRS?

No — both are non-custodial, KYC-free venues and neither issues 1099-DA. The difference is visibility: Lighter settles every deposit and withdrawal on public Ethereum L1, while Hyperliquid's ledger lives on its own chain. Neither makes you invisible; each just hides it in a different place.

?Which venue is easier for taxes?

Neither is easy. Hyperliquid has partial integrations that can look complete while truncating at a ~30-hour window. Lighter has no integrations but publishes its complete fill history as official parquet archives — a better source of truth, with nothing ready-made to consume it.

?Is funding treated the same on both?

Yes — hourly settlement on both venues, and the same unsettled guidance: conservative filers report funding received as ordinary income and funding paid as an expense; others net it into position PnL. The method question is identical; only the data source differs.

?I trade both — is that one record or two?

Two books, one filing. Each venue's fills stand alone; transfers between them (USDC out of one contract, into the other, via L1 or a CEX) are not disposals but must be matched so a withdrawal doesn't read as income and a deposit doesn't read as basis-free proceeds.

?Are the fee numbers comparable across the two?

No. Hyperliquid fees are signed and include maker rebates — a positive fee is income back to you. Lighter's typical account trades at zero fees; where fees apply they are a pure cost with no rebate stream. Don't net them with the same sign assumptions.

?If I only need one number — realized PnL — is the work the same?

Roughly, but the completeness check differs. On Hyperliquid you measure against a ~30-hour window and indexer coverage. On Lighter you check whether the window opened mid-position (a non-zero position_size_before on the first row) and whether the served span covers your account's real start. Both are the same question — 'where does my record actually begin?' — with different evidence.

Sources & method

See where your record actually starts — free

The Lighter trade API serves a rolling ~3-week window — and it can begin mid-position. The free gap check measures where that window starts against where your account actually did. Seconds, not minutes.

Measure my gap